Skip to main content
Custard Pecan Pie
Custard Pecan Pie

Custard Pecan Pie

$40.00

Our Custard Pecan Pie will begin shipping the week of November 2nd.

Our Custard Pecan Pie is a tribute to the kind of dessert that's been passed down through handwritten recipe cards and well-loved church cookbooks.  Our farm-fresh pecans are folded into a smooth, golden custard filling that bakes up sweet and rich without being heavy.  All of it rests inside a flaky, tender crust baked to perfection.  It's the pie that belongs at Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter...and just as easily on an ordinary Sunday afternoon when family drops by.  No frills.  No fuss.  Just the kind of dessert that makes people close their eyes after the first bite.

Serves 8-10 people.

Our homemade Custard Pecan Pie is ready to eat upon arrival. If you prefer, they can be enjoyed by warming in a 200 degree oven for 10-15 minutes, or until bubbly. The pies will remain fresh up to 1 week in the refrigerator. They can also be stored for up to 6 months in the freezer.

Our pecan pies are available for purchase from November through March. Please call the farm for special requests.

Some states require expedited shipping due to the perishable nature of this product. Please use the following guide to choose the correct shipping service.

UPS Ground-If you are shipping to Georgia, Florida, Alabama, South Carolina, North Carolina, Virginia, West Virginia, Tennessee, Mississippi, Louisiana, Arkansas, Missouri, Illinois, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania, New Jersey or Delaware.

Please choose UPS 2nd Day Air for all other states.

Due to their perishability, we typically ship our Custard Pecan Pie on Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday to arrive within 3 days from leaving our farm. Orders placed on Thursday or Friday may be held until the following Monday to ensure the 3 day transit time.

Return Policy

Pecans, Sugar, Buttermilk, Butter (Cream), Eggs, Flour, Vanilla, Enriched Flour, Soybean Oil, Water, Hydrogenated Cottonseed Oil, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Salt and Soy Flour

  • 5 stars: 30 (97%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (3%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
B
BH
A slice of heaven

This pie is very, very special! It tastes just like my late grandmother’s pies, which I haven’t experienced in 20 years. I didn’t know anyone could bake like this anymore. Thank you, thank you for the slice of heaven today you brought to me and my mom! Looking forward to trying the lemon and chocolate soon. Thank you, Pearson Farms, for your amazing and gorgeous products.

A
Alyson S.
The pie was wonderful

The pie was wonderful

C
Cynthia D.
1 star

Excellent flavor.
Crust superb.
Shipping incident, pie arrived with a hole on one side; it looked like someone took a spoon to it to taste it.

J
Johnny S.
The Custard pecan pie selection

The Custard pecan pie selection was super. The quality of the pecans and especially custard was beyond our expectation.
A simple summary....EVer item enclosed was perfect and the best we have ever had.
I only ask that you keep up the quality of your products. RATING --GREAT
JOHN SULFRIDGE

B
Betty M.
Pie

Love the pies! Now it’s time for your cakes again!

D
Deborah F.
Amazing

By far the best I’ve ever had. Worth every penny, you will not be disappointed.

L
Liz B.
Best pecan pie ever!

I'm from the south and have baked and eaten so many varieties of pecan pie and this one stands out as my favorite of all time! This shall be my birthday cake every year from now on lol. I always buy their pecans in the Shell too and I have never been disappointed by a bad crop, so grateful I found Pearson Farms.

H
Harry J.
All The Stars

I am a traditionalist when it comes to pecan pie. I do not like 75% of the other pies I have eaten because the crust matters and the store bought pie crust is just nasty. I did not like variations of what my mother fixed and she nailed the great crust every time. I was given one of these and was skeptical. It was great, reminded me of my mothers pecan pie and I cried a little.

M
Mark

Best I've had ever. Highly recommend this delicious pie.

M
Mark

Best I've had ever. Highly recommend this delicious pie.

J
Janet

A different version of pecan pie. The hubby loved it!

J
Janet

A different version of pecan pie. The hubby loved it!

T
Teresa M.
The pecan custard pie was

The pecan custard pie was wonderful!

R
Robert F.
Best Ever!

Best Pecan pie ever!.....
but, the better one was your Lemon Custard Pecan Pie that isn't available anymore! so sorry :(

S
Sarah B.
Very good

I’ve never had a pecan pie like this one. I loved the filling!!

K
Kathy B.
Great Pie

We ordered our first pecan pie earlier this year after hearing about it in a Pearson Farm e-mail. It's so hard to find a delicious pecan pie. This pie is great! We've ordered more of these pies since our first pie. It has become a favorite in our family. The pie also arrives extremely well packaged. I agree it would be a nice gift.

L
Laurie C.
Pecan Pie

Absolutely delicious…fresh and tastier than any homemade pie I’ve eaten. I ordered another!

R
RALPH P.
Great Birthday Gift

After making a error on my order, I called customer service. Explained my error to the lady and she was very professional correcting the order. The order was received when promised. The pie was DELICIOUS !!

C
Carol C.
Amazing - I gift these

Amazing - I gift these to everyone!

C
Carol J.
MOST DELICIOUS PIE EVER

This pie was the most delicious pie we have ever eaten. The crust was amazing and the custard was perfect and of course the most delicious pecans on top! Just ordered both the chocolate and custard pies for Christmas.

D
Deby B.
OMG YUMMY

We absolutely loved the pie & so did our clients!!

T
Tim

Always so excited to get my order! The best pecan pie ever!

T
Tim

Always so excited to get my order! The best pecan pie ever!

S
Susan P.
Simply the Best

Your Custard Pecan Pie is my hands down favorite pie on the planet! It is perfection! It is my Birthday "Pie," my celebration dessert, my Holiday go-to and my special gift to myself. It sets the gold standard for custard pecan pies. Sadly, it is out of season for almost half of the year and I am counting the days until I can order again. Thank you Pearson's for such a delicious, high quality product that arrives in perfect condition and for your outstanding peaches that are better than candy.

h
hope r.
Birthday pie

It was sent to my father for his 80th birthday he and my mother said it was wonderful! Same as all my other purchases Pearson farms has never disappointed. Cant wait for peach season. Gold standard service!!!

J
Jama B.
Exceptional!

This is by far the best pecan custard pie I have ever eaten! The crust is so flaky, custard filling is smooth with just the right amount of sweetness, and the crunchy pecan layer on top is just the final touch to all already amazing symphony of flavors. If you want to taste a real flavor of the south that will sure to be memorable...this is the pie for you!

G
Guy C.
Custard pecan

Very good but not keto change subject pound cake is freezable till thanksgiving time that’s what I thought someone said

D
Dan B.
An all time best. Highly

An all time best. Highly recommended!

L
Lelita S.
Custard Pecan Pie

The pie was simply delicious, crust was flaky I usually don’t eat it but it was great

S
Susan T.
Great Pie

There is not much better than a great Pecan Pie...it depends on great pecans, which they have.

J
John P.
Very good :satisfied:

Very good :satisfied: